Friday, 20 October 2017

Selected Student Resources - The Next Stage of the Inquiry

For this next step, our task was to curate ten resources for student use during the inquiry assignment. I believe that I have selected a nice range of resources as I would hope to do in the classroom as well; I have included print books such as textbooks, novels for a literary take on the topic, blog posts, social media analysis sites, a peer-reviewed journal, and TED talks. At this point in the inquiry process I feel that these are the best resources to meet students' diverse learning needs as well as appeal to their interests. However, once I come closer to finalizing the inquiry unit, things may change. As with all things inquiry -- it is a work in progress.




Anderson, M.T. (2002). Feed. Somerville: Candlewick Press.
Feed is set in the near-future where the internet has been hardwired into the vast majority of the population’s brains. The protagonist, Titus, and his friends find themselves in the midst of a hack where their feeds have been compromised and are now unavailable while under repair. The novel chronicles the youths’ journey as they struggle with the desire to stay connected to their feed for every moment each day.
Feed has won multiple book awards and has garnered much popularity amongst youth and adults alike because it does what dystopian novels do so well - reflects and amplifies the quirks of our world. I chose this novel for possible study because it looks at what our world could be rather than what currently is. Students could study the effects of social media through a literary lens as Titus and friends become “unplugged” and find that they struggle to exist in their new world. Suggested for older teens, Feed comes in at just over three hundred pages making it a manageable read for students at grade level.

2.
Broadbent, Stephanie. (July 2009). “How the Internet Enables Intimacy.” [Video file]. Retrieved from https://www.ted.com/talks/stefana_broadbent_how_the_internet_enables_intimacy on October 11, 2017.

The TED talk comes in at less than 9 minutes and Broadbent uses real-world examples to present her research. This talk provides a slightly different perspective to the connections that the internet has brought to our lives. Broadbent argues that the internet and social media tools such as Skype, have actually provided closer connections that were not possible previously. Many of the resources that students will use will cast social media and technology in a very negative light; however, it is important for students to also be provided with the alternate view so they have a broader perspective of the topic. While the talk may be considered slightly dated in the technology world, the information provided is still relevant and is presented in a very accessible manner.

3.  
Freitas, Donna. (2017). The Happiness Effect: How Social Media is Driving a Generation to Appear Perfect at Any Cost. New York: Oxford University Press.

Freitas’ latest book has been constructed through surveys and interviews with college students. Its 350+ pages feature student interviews framed with assertions by Freitas. The book centers on how social media forces a sort-of perfect life syndrome whereby individuals only see the perfect life of others and feel that they can only share the positive aspects of their own lives. This leads to feelings of isolation and low self-worth as one’s real life can never compare with the perfection portrayed online.
The appeal of this book is that Freitas’ conclusions come through discussions with young people making it easy to digest and relate to. While the book is quite lengthy, Freitas narrows down a theme for each of the eleven chapters that students could focus on rather than reading the book in its entirety.

4.
Hall, M., Elliott, K., & Meng, J. (2017). “Using the PAD (Pleasure, Arousal, and Dominance) Model to Explain Facebook Attitudes and Use Intentions.” Journal Of Social Media In Society, 6(1), 144-167. Retrieved from http://thejsms.org/index.php/TSMRI/article/view/230/118

This article discusses the use of Facebook with the framework of the Pleasure, Arousal, and Dominance Model. A scientific study is conducted to determine various reasons for using Facebook. The article is twenty six pages in length, includes a hypothesis, results and areas for future study. As such it provides a much more concrete approach to the study of social media than some of the other sources. This resource would be particularly useful for those students who appreciate a more scientific approach.
It should be noted that this entire journal is freely available online, accessible for students, and is a peer reviewed source. Realistically, rather that one specific article, I would recommend the journal as a whole for students’ use demonstrating how to search within the journal by topic, or to browse through each issue. This journal allows students to dig deeper into their specific focus on social media using current research, which would provide a nice complement to some of the other sources.

5.
Homzie, Hillary. (2016). Queen of Likes. New York: Aladdin.
Queen of Likes is a fiction reader that demonstrates both the power in popularity on social media through the adolescent population, as well as how addicted we can become to our phone and the social media apps it holds. It follows the story of Karma Cooper who is very popular online. After misusing her phone Karma has her phone privileges revoked and she must learn to adapt to her life without her phone.
I had multiple fiction resources on my list but wanted to narrow it down to two - one lower level and one grade level. This one made the list because it covers not only how all encompassing social media can become in our lives -- driving our popularity and our behaviour -- but also how we find our world changed when we remove the presence of social media. I appreciated that this resource is accessible for lower level readers while engaging in the topic in an interesting manner.

6.
Kerpen, Dave. (2011). Likeable Social Media: How to Delight Your Customers, Create an Irresistible Brand, and Be Generally Amazing on Facebook (and other social networks). New York: McGraw Hill Companies.

A book geared toward those looking to use social media for marketing, Likeable Social Media also demonstrates how individuals use social media to garner success in both their personal and professional world. Kerpen provides eighteen strategies to get social media working for you. Each chapter focuses on one of the eighteen strategies in an engaging manner. While the book as a whole would be too much for students, the eighteen strategy chapter division would allow students to hone in on areas of Kerpen’s approach that appeal to their inquiry. The book is very strongly reviewed both by marketing executives and other authors in the social media field. Its readability and clear focus would make it a good resource for students hoping to focus on the business end of social media.

7.
Newberry, C., & Dawley, S. (2017). “How to Get More Instagram Followers: The Ultimate Guide.” Hootsuite Social Media Management. Retrieved 6 October 2017, from https://blog.hootsuite.com/how-to-get-more-instagram-followers-the-ultimate-guide/
This article provides a clear eleven point strategy to tailor your instagram account for maximum popularity. Through the use of subheadings, visual examples, and concise explanations, the article provides an uncomplicated guide for readers to follow and implement. The post stays as concise as possible using one line “do’s” and “don’ts”. Geared towards those in the marketing world, the tips provided would generally work for anyone trying to increase their online following.
The article is published by Hootsuite which is a social media management platform, that also offers free social media education in the form of webinars and blog posts. I would use this article to introduce students to Hootsuite itself - which they could then use to follow their inquiry in their desired direction. As a class we would discuss the inherent bias and purpose behind the Hootsuite articles so that students would view the content with a more critical lens. The blog and webisodes are very user-friendly full of neat visuals to accompany key points about their chosen topic. The content should be accessible to all levels in the classroom with those students who prefer to learn visually making use of the webinars.

8.
Probst, Caitlin. (2015) “10 Ways Social Media Affects Our Mental Health.” Degreed website. Retrieved October 11, 2017, from http://blog.degreed.com/10-ways-social-media-affects-our-mental-health/.

This blog post written by Probst narrows down the ten main ways that social media affects our mental health. It discusses both positive and negative aspects of social media on our mental health and cites scientific studies to back up its claims. While there are many blog posts written on this topic and the vast majority of them are very readable and nice to look at, this blog post stood out as it wasn’t heavily swayed towards one side or the other (both positive and negative aspects? This was a rare find!), and it cited reputable sources such as Medical News Today and Science Daily. It is nice to see a blog post actually supporting its claims with sources which allows students to investigate the sources even further.  

9.
Raatma, Lucia. (2013). Cyberbullying (True Books: Guides to Life). New York: Scholastic.

Cyberbullying is a nonfiction reader that focuses on the bullying aspect of social media. It discusses the various ways one can be a victim of cyberbullying, as well as giving tips on prevention and how to deal with cyberbullying if it does happen.
I chose this resource because it is a very accessible lower-level non-fiction source. It talks about some of the various negative aspects that social media can bring into our lives in a way that is easy for students to understand. This resource would be suitable for all students in the classroom but is mainly geared to those who struggle with comprehension skills.

10.
Turkle, Sherry. (February, 2012). “Connected, but alone?” [Video File] Retrieved from https://www.ted.com/talks/sherry_turkle_alone_together on October 11, 2017.

A twenty-five minute TED Talk on the paradox of how technology provides us a new level of connectedness, while remaining more distant than before. While this talk doesn’t focus on social media specifically as it looks at technology as a whole, the conclusions drawn are certainly applicable to social media connectedness.  
Turkle provides examples of people texting while in the company of others at important events such as at board meetings, and even at funerals. She provides context for herself by stating that in 1995 she was on the cover of Wired Magazine for authoring a book about the exciting new world technology is bringing us into; she comes back to the present about the isolating world technology has actually created for us.
This resource would be appealing to all students as it is a quick, digestible talk in language that is accessible to a variety of levels. Turkle speaks at a nice pace, provides good examples to demonstrate her relatability, and summarizes her conclusions well. Students can use this resource as a reference for how our intended use of technology has changed over the years, and how we have changed as a result.






Wednesday, 11 October 2017

Right in the thick of it.....Learning Log 1.2


Module 5: Selecting Resources for Inquiry


"Does a school district have an obligation to provide more than the booklet? How should districts and/or teacher unions ensure that teachers are familiar with these new conditions for respecting copyright? What are the consequences of violating the terms, wittingly or otherwise?"


I really appreciated this prompt as it gave me some focus for this Module's Learning Log. In looking at the resources for this module including the ERAC, the Copyright Matters booklet, and other blog posts, I am quickly feeling overwhelmed. The next assignment in our project is creating the Annotated Bibliography - ie. resource selection for our inquiry unit. This now feels like a daunting task with all of these guidelines that I wasn't quite aware of before.
Image Retrieved from Cayman News

Like many teachers, I was aware of the basic copyright restrictions through the Copyright Matters Resource. The one that stuck in my head is the 10% rule: for educational purposes copies could be made of up to 10% of a work for classroom use (Noel & Snel, 2016). This resource is a very handy tool for understanding basic copyright guidelines when it comes to print resources, but does not begin to touch digital resources. As many in the discussion board have already posted - this is an area that we hadn't really considered before. For example, I was unaware that I could use my personal Netflix account in the classroom as it violated the Terms of Use agreement with Netflix which is for household use only (Netflix Terms of Use, 2017). Additionally, any music played in the classroom is to be for educational purposes only - ie. it is not allowed for a teacher to have music playing in the background while the students are working (Noel & SNel, 2016). I am learning these guidelines as a result of this course - not through any effort on the part of the district(s) I belong to.

As so many of us are unaware of all of the guidelines surrounding copyright, I think it prudent that district's provide more than just the booklet to inform educators. I believe this topic is worthy of an annual Pro-D (though one wouldn't necessarily need to attend annually), allowing educators to brush up on the topic. This would allow teachers to have designated time to brush up on any changes that may have occurred since they last familiarized themselves with copyright law. Though the Pro-D could be presented annually (for the benefit of any teachers who may be new to the system), teachers should only be required to attend every 5 years (or so - depending on when major changes come about).

Continuing On.....Beginning the Bibliography

So, assignment two is fast approaching and it is to complete an annotated bibliography. I truly appreciate how in this course the assignments build upon themselves and we end up leaving (hopefully) with a completed unit ready to use in the classroom. I knew that I wanted to come at the annotated bibliography intelligently, that is, use a bibliography that I could use within my inquiry unit. That means jumping into my inquiry unit earlier than I was hoping -- who doesn't love to procrastinate on that big project after all? As I am currently on maternity leave I was struggling with how to come up with a list of resources that I would make available to students; not being attached to a school library at the moment does pose a few challenges - but I am very grateful for this one - I learned a lesson!

I decided to come at the resource curation from the point of view of students outside the classroom. Yes, I agree with our instructor that teaching how to use search databases is a much more intelligent way of going about resource selection; however, I also feel that if I am teaching students how to learn, then why not teach them with the tools I know they have available to them? Namely, Google. So, simply with the use of Google and some out of the box searching, I have managed to select seven resources already that I think are pretty great. My first excellent find was a published journal exactly on the inquiry topic: The Journal of Social Media in Society. This journal is a scholarly publication that is freely available and fully accessible online! Aside from this excellent resource that far surpassed my expectations I have selected novels at varying reading levels, non-fiction resources on my topic, as well as blogs by experts! I am getting jazzed up about the possibility of putting this unit into place with these excellent tools for students! Who knew resource selection would help me feel that this project is possible?

Module 6: Curation - continued!


There were two articles in this module that I found particularly helpful, and I am noting here for the sole (well, almost) purpose that I can easily refer back to them at my convenience. I have noticed that during my TL Diploma I have come across so many excellent resources through course readings, the professor's specific recommendations, or other students - yet in the busyness of the course I have lost track of so many! I am hoping that this blog will help in that regard, yet I digress.


The first article that I have found to be exceptionally valuable is Abilock's "How can students know whether the information they find online is true -- or not?". The article points our four key aspects in judging online resources - importance, trustworthiness, accuracy, and info-graphics - and gives advice on how to judge each part. The article also points out the usefulness of Wikipedia and how to teach students to use it effectively; ie. how to judge which pages are more trustworthy. I enjoyed the overall readability of the article as well as the clear points to look out for when judging an article's usefulness.


The second article from this module that I am noting for safekeeping is Bromann-Bender's "You can't fool me: Website evaluation". This article provides a comprehensive approach to teaching website evaluation including how to effectively introduce the topic (with some example website), and some pre-search tips such as using boolean search phrases, and also includes an excellent handout for students to use during their evaluations. I appreciated that the authors acknowledge that teaching this lesson to students doesn't eliminate all poor website choices, but it does open a dialogue regarding website evaluation. The one negative aspect of this article is that it is slightly outdated. In the pre-search tips Bromann-Bender suggests using the Internet Public Library (www.ipl.org) for student searches as a way of narrowing the search to better resources. However, while the IPL is still available for use it is no longer maintained and no new articles are added. However, the remainder of the article was useful and and well worth keeping a copy of.



References Used


Abilock, D. (2012). How can students know whether the information they find online is true – or not? Educational Leadership 69(6): 70-74.

Bromann-Bender, J. (2013). “You Can’t fool me: Website evaluation.” Library Media Connection 31(5):42-45.

Hall, M., Elliott, K., & Meng, J. (2017). Using the PAD (Pleasure, Arousal, and Dominance) Model to Explain Facebook Attitudes and Use Intentions. Journal Of Social Media In Society, 6(1), 144-167. Retrieved from http://thejsms.org/index.php/TSMRI/article/view/230/118

Netflix Terms of Use (2017). Help.netflix.com. Retrieved 4 October 2017, from https://help.netflix.com/legal/termsofuse

Noel, W. & Snel, J. (2016). Copyright matters! (4rd edition). Ottawa, ON: Council of Ministers of Education (CMEC), Canadian School Boards Association (CSBA), and Canadian Teachers’ Federation (CTF). Rertrieved 4 October 2017, from http://cmec.ca/Publications/Lists/Publications/Attachments/291/Copyright_Matters.pdf



Wednesday, 27 September 2017

Thursday September 7, 2017 - The Beginning... (Learning Log 1.1)

In approaching this course I knew that the smartest way to go about things is to have at least a fuzzy notion of what I wanted to do for my inquiry unit; if I had a general direction then the readings and bibliography would be much more focused than if I just ambled through the course. However, not having any experience whatsoever with inquiry, I had no idea where to begin.

The brief times I had heard inquiry referenced previously it was always with a Science unit where students could explore a topic of choice from their unit. It sounded great - but I had no idea how to take that principle of self-exploration and apply it to English. So, when approaching a new topic and unsure of how to start I did what I usually do - I turned to Google. A very quick Google search brought me to this article by fellow English teacher, Tina Barseghian.  Maybe it's not one of our required readings but before I could dive into the readings and acquire information, I needed to be able to have a context for my learning. I could be ashamed of the fact that I feel I need examples before I can move forward, or I can simply acknowledge that that's how I work best. I'm choosing to do the latter and remind myself that my students may need similar accommodations to be able to participate in the messy world of inquiry. The article itself chronicles one English teacher's use of inquiry in the classroom and a few examples of what it looks like for her and her students. The student-led aspect of inquiry is particularly exciting to me as I find that students become much more engaged when they feel involved in their own learning.


Module One - Why Inquiry?


I think the inquiry approach has been necessary and on its way for some time. I remember sitting in a high school classroom memorizing a Social Studies textbook of facts and wondering...what's the point? Why do I need to memorize these names and dates (memory is not my strong suit) when I can simply reference them in this book? This was taken a step further with the invention of the Internet (just really taking off when I was in school), and compounded with the tremendous power of Google. Now I have wondered myself - why am I asking students to memorize names and dates when they can look them up in two seconds with their phone? Why aren't we teaching students what to do with the information that is at their fingertips?

Well, one simple reason that inquiry had not yet become part of the standard teaching method is that change is hard. Making such a drastic change from a structured to teaching method to an inquiry based approach can be daunting. Our curriculum is now being revised to consider a more inquiry based approach which can be seen in the Core Competencies which place a strong emphasis on Creative and Critical Thinking, as well as in the individual subject areas. In Senior English, for example, there is not one set course for all students; instead, the course is broken down into five separate strands that allow students to pursue their interests. Within these strands there are Big Ideas which guide the student and teacher to pursue much larger ideas within the topic. When the draft curriculum was first proposed I was excited about the idea that students could be able to pursue their own interests - yet daunted as a teacher about how this would work. Considering the new curriculum through an inquiry lens allows me to see that this change is much more possible.

In considering my Inquiry unit I was baffled at how to begin. So after conversation with my husband who is also a teacher (collaboration is good!) I decided to start with one of the Big Ideas from the draft of the New Media English 11 course. The Big Idea that I chose is: People understand text differently depending on their worldviews and perspectives. I'm not quite sure where to take it yet but at least I have a start.



Module Two: Parameters of Inquiry

One key point of inquiry is to adjust as you go along; it seems that this blog post is getting rather lengthy so I started taking notes on the course separately so that I could reflect on the most important aspects to post here. I probably should have started this way but at least I am learning as I'm going.

In Ekdahl's "Points of Inquiry" article, I was struck by the assertion that “Students need to find the right resources for their purposes, including books, journals, and databases; how to evaluate sources critically”. (Ekdahl, "Point of Inquiry", 2014) I connected with this quote in particular because it is no longer important to just remember information that is presented, but how to sift through the wealth of knowledge that is so readily available to them. Connecting this to my Inquiry unit - there is so much false news and misinformation being spread through social media like facebook that people are taking at face value. We need to teach our students to be critical of the information that they are presented with.

Further in this article (I found this one quite useful), Ekdahl provides a chart of what inquiry based reading and learning should look like in each grade range. I found this to be a particularly useful tool as it not only provided concrete examples of what inquiry should look like at each level, but also offered up instructional strategies for implementation. This article, along with Barbara Stripling's "Inquiry-Based Learning" have been saved for future reference for this inquiry unit, and others to come. Stripling's chapter also provides an excellent chart connecting inquiry strategies and skills, to literacy skills and teaching strategies. I find these tools particularly useful in navigating the murky water of inquiry - though the water is getting slightly clearer each day.

Module Three: The Inquiry Mindset

What I've learned throughout Module Three is that my personal teaching philosophy is very connected with the idea of inquiry. My personal philosophy has been centered around the idea that all students are capable of succeeding when the optimal conditions are present. I have always believed that students needed to feel engaged in their learning (Connect and Wonder), and confident to make leaps (and mistakes). I always struggled with how to provide this opportunity for all students, settling for presenting the material in a few different ways, as well as providing options for students to present their learning. Sir Ken Robinson's TED talk "Escaping Education's Death Valley" connected to me here; Robinson used the metaphor of death valley being not dead, but dormant - and our students are the same when optimal conditions are provided - this was somewhat of an 'aha' moment for me. The inquiry approach can provide students with both the desire to learn and buy in to what we are teaching (or facilitating), as well as give them the confidence to take risks in their learning. The more I learn about inquiry, the more excited I become. Now...to get more of a handle on the process itself!
Inquiry Project Status Report

Since the Learning Log is meant to keep track of our learning I thought it would be important to not only chronicle what I am learning about inquiry in the course, but how the inquiry unit project is going, the process I am taking, and where my roadblocks are.

My current Inquiry Unit plan is a very very rough outline. I started,  as mentioned above, with one of the Big Ideas from the New Media 11 curriculum. This led me to draft my overarching Inquiry question: How does social media impact our lives? So, I had a question - now what? Well I didn't really know, so after drafting my question I watched Wright's YouTube video on "The Model of Inquiry" to get a grasp of the inquiry process according to Stripling's model. This video was a good introduction with a real-world example (purchasing a new tablet) of the inquiry process. Through watching this video I was able to create this rough outline of my unit so far:

6 phases of inquiry:
  • 1. Connect to yourself - what do I already know about social media / when do I use it? Which ones do I use?
  • 2.Wonder - create questions you want answered: What are the other uses for social media? How do we alter ourselves on social media? Is it true or a misrepresentation? How often do we check sites like Facebook and Twitter? What do we use it for?
  • 3. Investigate: What resources use? The sites themselves, personal interviews, blog posts,
  • 4. Construct - connect new knowledge with previous knowledge...???
  • 5. Express - share knowledge with others - present somehow - the before and after effect - how we change ourselves for social media? Our Facebook/Instagram life compared to reality - poster, Prezi, YouTube video, skit, common craft video,
  • 6. Reflect - on the inquiry process itself - what did you learn, how did you go about it, what would you do differently, which resources worked, which didn't - can use an online journal tool or something to present reflection - or have students brainstorm how they want to reflect - create handout for future students?

As you can see - this is really just a skeleton of an outline. I had this outline for a few days and was a bit stuck on how to proceed. Thankfully, I have a wonderful Professor who is guiding our Inquiry course with a lot of support; she recently posted in the Discussion Forum a post on Tips for thinking about Assignment 3. In this post she mentions that one of the first things we will want to focus on is what we want students to know, do and understand from this unit. Now, instead of spinning rudderless, I have been given a clear direction of what to focus on next. I am starting to see through my own experience in Inquiry, and with a great role model, how the teacher can be a supportive facilitator. Now to get working!

References:

    • BC Ministry of Education. (2013). BC's New Curriculum. Victoria, BC: BC Ministry of Education
      Barseghian, T., & Wright, S. (2017). Life in a 21st-Century English Class. MindShift. Retrieved 8 September 2017, from https://ww2.kqed.org/mindshift/2011/12/21/life-in-a-21st-century-english-class/
      Ekdahl, M., Farquharson, M., Robinson, J. & Turner, L. (2010). Points of Inquiry: A Framework For Information Literacy and The 21st Century Learner. Vancouver, BC: BC Teacher Librarians’ Association (BCTLA) and BC Teachers’ Federation (BCTF).
      Robinson, K. (2013). Ken Robinson: How to Escape Education’s Death Valley. TEDTalks. YouTube. Retrieved 23 September 2017, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wX78iKhInsc
      Stripling, B. K. (2003). Inquiry-based learning. In Curriculum Connections through the Library. Eds. B. K. Stripling & S. Hughes-Hassell. Westport, CT: Libraries Unlimited.
      Wright, M. (2014). The model of inquiry. YouTube. Retrieved 18 September 2017, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KnqNFl-BDfE

Sunday, 21 February 2016

Curation of Challenged Books


Some Context

One of the assignments that I am tasked with completing for my coursework is a curation of Children's Literature. We have the freedom to choose any books that we like, but the books should be centered around a theme.

In preparation for this assignment I started researching and thinking about various themes: nerdy books, action stories, classic children's literature, top book picks....and so on. The lists are endless, and they are all wonderful. I did stumble across one idea that caught my eye: challenged books. The beauty of the challenged book is that it can fall into any of the categories that I listed above; yet it also has the added intrigue of being challenged. Why was it challenged? Who challenged it? How many books are challenged? Right away I was inspired by the idea of addressing challenged books. 






Rationale for Challenged Books

I set out to create this curation not necessarily to find specific answers to questions like those mentioned above, but to prompt a discussion about what causes literature to be challenged, and to address the value of keeping challenged literature in the classroom. 

After I began my search of challenged books – first in Canada, and then expanded to the U.S. – I was surprised at how many of my favourite titles were on the list! Apparently, I love controversial books! Some of the books like Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, or The Absolutely True Diary of a Part Time Indian, I was unsurprised to see on the list.  I had heard the controversy around these books and knew that they had been challenged. However, even classics like To Kill A Mockingbird, Of Mice and Men, and The Lord of the Flies were also popping up on my challenged list. I was shocked to see that classic literature that was taught to me in high school had been challenged. So, what could possibly be in these books that my English teachers found so valuable that warranted them being challenged?


Figure 1

Reasons for Challenge

What are the common reasons that books are challenged? In a search of freedomtoread.ca and the ALA's 100 Most Frequently Challenged Books, the same reasons cropped up over and over. The same reasons in fact, that are depicted in Figure 1: "unsuited to age group", "offensive language", "moral/religions reasons" and so on. In essence, we are not trusting children to handle the material that is presented in the book. We do not deem children capable to handle the material. However, if we are not allowing the children to be guided through difficult literature in the classroom with sensitivity and awareness, are we truly preparing children for analysing difficult literature, and the material presented in it, on their own? In Susan Fanetti's article "A Case for Cultivating Controversy: Teaching Challenged Books in the K-12 Classroom", she argues that "by preventing [children] from gaining knowledge of and experience with those ideas, we will make them incapable of understanding them" (2012). Restricting children's access to challenged material doesn't protect them, but leaves them unprepared for facing it in the future. 


In Defence of the Challenged Book

Challenged books, are by their very name, thought-provoking. They present sensitive topics and difficult issues that must be handled delicately. Yet they are also named as such because they challenge us, our beliefs and our thinking. Challenged books force us to step outside our comfort zone of the accepted 'normal'. Not teaching challenged works to students is just one form of censorship, and demonstrates that we don't view the students as capable of handling the material. However, as teachers and parents who are confident enough to allow their children to read challenged literature find, children are quite capable - when given the right tools. Going back to Fanetti's article, "when we take the opportunity to share challenging work with children and are available and open to their questioning and discussion, their potential to understand increases commensurately". With our guidance, students are very capable of handling the material in challenged works - and are better off for it!



My "15"

In searching "challenged books" it becomes apparent quite quickly that there would certainly be no shortage of books to choose from. The ALA's  list is not named "The 100 Books that have been challenged" rather, it is named "The 100 Most Frequently Challenged Books". I thought it would be difficult to narrow my choices down when there were so many choices; however, the choice of my 15 challenged books was simple. Books had to meet the first two of the following criteria, and preference was given to the third:

1. Challenged at least once for its use in schools in North America
2. Books that were commonly read by students today either as part of a school's curriculum or because of its own popularity
3. Books that may fall into a "Classics" category

One of the interesting things about searching through the list of challenged books, was how many of the titles would today, typically be considered Classic Literature. This both shocked and amused me: these titles, heralded by English teachers today, were once (and some quite recently), thought inappropriate for the classroom? Yet now we sing their praises and encourage (force)  English students everywhere to read them. . . I think that there is an important social and cultural lesson in that for both teachers and students. What is considered appropriate now, likely wasn't a number of decades ago. 

I also chose books that had a fairly broad age range. Bridge to Terabithia and The Giver are generally taught around age 10-11. The Handmaid's Tale, on the other hand, is generally taught in senior English, around age 16-17. The reason that I specifically chose books from a broad age range is because I think challenged books are important over the course of an education, and not just once a student reaches high school. While I focused my selection on challenged Literary Works, I included a few that would fall outside this category such as Staying Fat for Sarah Byrnes, and The Face on the Milk Carton; these books are quite widely read and appreciated - both in the classroom, and outside of it. 

I really like the idea of teaching a course or creating a display in the library around challenged books, and especially literature. I would teach the students the novel, but with the added layer of also teaching the context from which it was challenged. This would encourage students to think about the book from a new perspective and understand how people of another time felt. It is important to understand this particular context to really grasp the literature's intent, as well. Really, any grounded English teacher should be teaching context with novels; however, going a step further and addressing the challenged around the novel would add further depth and perspective to the students' understanding. 


Challenged Literary Works






Other, Popular Challenged Books




Bibliography of Chosen Books

Alexie, Sherman. The Absolutely True Diary Of A Part-Time Indian. New York: Little, Brown, 2007. Print.
Atwood, Margaret. The Handmaid's Tale. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1986. Print.
Bradbury, Ray. Fahrenheit 451. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1967. Print.
Cooney, Caroline B. The Face On The Milk Carton. New York: Bantam Books, 1990. Print.
Crutcher, Chris. Staying Fat For Sarah Byrnes. New York, N.Y.: Greenwillow Books, 1993. Print.
Lee, Harper. To Kill A Mockingbird. Philadelphia: Lippincott, 1960. Print.
Lowry, Lois. The Giver. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1993. Print.
Golding, William. Lord Of The Flies. New York: Coward-McCann, 1962. Print.
Huxley, Aldous. Brave New World. New York: Perennial Classics, 1998. Print.
Keyes, Daniel. Flowers For Algernon. New York: Harcourt, Brace & World, 1966. Print.
Orwell, George. Animal Farm. New York: Knopf, 1993. Print.
Paterson, Katherine. Bridge To Terabithia. New York, NY: T.Y. Crowell, 1977. Print.
Rowling, J. K. Harry Potter And The Philosopher's Stone. London: Bloomsbury, 2001. Print.
Steinbeck, John. Of Mice And Men. New York: Penguin Books, 1993. Print.
Twain, Mark. The Adventures Of Huckleberry Finn. New York, N.Y.: Baronet Books, 1990. Print.







References


Ala.org, (2016). 100 most frequently challenged books: 1990–1999 | Banned & Challenged Books. [online] Available at: http://www.ala.org/bbooks/100-most-frequently-challenged-books-1990%E2%80%931999 [Accessed 21 Feb. 2016].

Fanetti, S. (2012). ALAN v40n1 - A Case for Cultivating Controversy: Teaching Challenged Books in K–12 Classrooms. [online] Scholar.lib.vt.edu. Available at: https://scholar.lib.vt.edu/ejournals/ALAN/v40n1/fanetti.html [Accessed 30 Jan. 2016].

Freedomtoread.ca, (2016). Challenged Works. [online] Available at: http://www.freedomtoread.ca/challenged-works/ [Accessed 21 Feb. 2016].

Said, S. (2015, September 29). Can children's books help build a better world? Available at:http://www.theguardian.com/childrens-books-site/2015/sep/29/childrens-books-build-a-better-world-sf-said [Accessed January 3, 2016].


Note: All images retrieved from a Google image search of "Challenged books" 

We Are Water

I recently finished reading Wally Lamb's book We Are Water.


If you have read my previous review on The Goldfinch, you will already be aware that I am not fond of reading the book's sleeve in its entirety. Instead, I read a few sentences and then decide to jump into the story. . . or not! This was my tactic with Wally Lamb's book as well. As a result, all I knew going into the book was that Annie Oh had left a marriage of twenty seven years for a woman.

The book is truly centered around the Oh family, their past, and how they got to the place they are at. It started off quite slowly with the narrative focused on character development rather than plot. In the end while it is worth it to get a sense of who these characters are and where their motivations come from, I felt the build was unnecessarily slow. Though the story is mostly focused around Annie, and her now-ex husband Orion, it also gives brief glimpses into the lives of the three children, as well as Annie's fiancĂ©e, Viveca.

While slow at the beginning, the pacing certainly picks up about one-third to halfway through the story. The narrative itself switches from Annie's, to Orion's, to the children's point-of-view, among others. The timeframe also switches from the present, to the crux of the Oh's marriage breakdown, to even further into Annie's past. We Are Water is beautifully written and demonstrates how even if we think we can escape our past and its many ghosts, it will always surface in our present.

I deducted half a star for the tedious start of the novel, but other than that the book would be a solid four stars. It is well written, contains interesting characters who are nicely developed, and shows the growth and change of people over time as a result of our circumstances. Okay, so does any novel ever but this book is great and is definitely worth reading!

Tuesday, 2 February 2016

The Goldfinch by Donna Tartt

I thought I would start off my book reviews with one of my recent reads - Donna Tart's The Goldfinch.




This was a book that was coming up over and over again on must read lists, best-sellers, and of course, Goodreads. And then the cover won it's beautiful golden stamp - The Pullitzer Prize. Everyone was in agreement - this novel was great! After much resistance (I tend to avoid books that are super popular, for awhile and then I give in) I picked up the Goldfinch from my library and began my journey. The size of the book itself is a bit daunting, coming in at 760 pages. However, right away the book draws the reader in.

I began to read the book with very little fore-knowledge, my preferred method of reading (who else hates book-flap spoilers? Anyone?). I prefer going into a book knowing very little of what is about to happen.

The story starts off describing a traumatic event in Theo's childhood. I don't want to say too much about it as it is a worthwhile read...It is from this singular event that the rest of the narrative unravels. We follow Theo as he navigates adolescence, as well as watching him in adulthood.

The Goldfinch truly does center around Theo and the events in his life; however, Tartt's character development surely has to be one of her main strengths as a writer. Even if we wouldn't be making the same choices that we see Theo making, Tartt's description of his character is so vivid that we understand the why very clearly. And of course no one grows up alone in life, and Tartt has blessed the narrative with other brilliant characters to allow the novel to shine even brighter. We meet Boris, Theo's childhood friend - one of the most interesting characters in the novel. Pippa, a young girl who was part of the same traumatic event that Theo was. And then there is Hobie, the loveable older gentleman that takes Theo under his wing when it is needed most.

Not a particularly plot driven novel, The Goldfinch is driven by the incredible characters that Donna Tartt has brought to life. As readers we yearn to find out where Theo is going next, and what unfortunate circumstance he may find himself in. Rather slow-paced for its size, The Goldfinch is nevertheless worth following through to witness Theo as he navigates the choppy waters of life.